I have been making homemade yogurt now for almost 2 years. The funny thing is...I hate yogurt. Blech! But, my kids love it and I love making it for them. I get to make the exact flavors they like without all the added sugar the store bought kind has.
Their favorite flavor is simple - cinnamon vanilla! They eat yogurt every.single.day. I think they'd eat it with every meal if I let them (how are they my kids?!?)
Now don't get me wrong, I occasionally buy yogurt from the store - mainly when we travel.
I once bought Greek yogurt for Elena and she called it ice cream! I just went with it and let her call it that!
The thing I like about Greek yogurt, is how thick it is. With my homemade yogurt, it thins out, especially when I add in the "flavoring" (vanilla, pureed fruit, etc). Because Greek yogurt is so thick, I don't notice that it gets any thinner when I add fruit or vanilla to it.
The bummer part of Greek yogurt though, is how expensive it is. One of those single serving size cups (6 ounces usually) costs more than $1 and sometimes closer to $2!!! The other negative, is that the majority of Greek yogurt sold in the stores here is nonfat. Meaning zero fat.
It's no secret that my kids are barely on the growth curve (they are on their own growth curve and are very healthy!), so for now I continue to give them milk products that are at a minimum made with 2% milk. When I make their yogurt, I make it with whole milk (that also helps it be thicker). I have never even come across whole milk Greek yogurt in a store.
Lately, when I have been making their yogurt, I try to pour off the whey that accumulates in the glass jars (whey is the clearish liquid). Since I was already doing that, I decided to check online to see how to make the yogurt Greek style.
It is so completely easy - that I feel like an idiot for not doing it sooner!
If you aren't familiar with how I make yogurt, check out my previous blog post here.
The only thing you do differently to make it Greek, is this:
Once your yogurt is done culturing, place it in the fridge for approximately 3 hours.
After 3 hours, remove from fridge.
Line a mesh strainer with 4 layers of cheesecloth and set the strainer over a medium to large mixing bowl.
Spoon your yogurt into the cheesecloth lined strainer.
Set the entire bowl/strainer/yogurt contraption back in the fridge for about another hour.
After an hour, remove from fridge.
The whey will be in the bottom of the mixing bowl and your nice thick Greek yogurt is sitting in the cheesecloth!
That's it, your Greek yogurt is complete (after flavoring of course).
I used 4 cups of organic whole milk to make my Greek Yogurt. A gallon of organic whole milk cost me just under $6 at the grocery store (and I only used a QUARTER of that gallon). My yogurt starter came from a previous batch of yogurt that I had made. A 32 ounce container of Greek Chobani yogurt at the grocery store costs about $5-$6, depending on sale price vs. regular price.
Greek yogurt!
